When Being the Strong One Becomes Who You Are

How our greatest strengths can become expectations, why capable women struggle to put themselves first, and what happens when we begin questioning the identities we’ve built.

I’ve been thinking about something rather unusual recently.

And it began at the theatre.

I went to see a production of Kafka’s The Hunger Artist.

It’s a fascinating story about a man whose identity becomes inseparable from his ability to endure.

And while watching it, I found myself considering a question that has stayed with me ever since.

When does something we choose to do become something we no longer know how to stop doing?

It’s a question that extends far beyond the theatre.

Because I think many of us develop behaviours that begin as conscious choices but eventually become part of how we define ourselves.

And sometimes, without noticing, we stop questioning them.

The expectations we inherit

I think many women grow up with a fairly clear understanding of what being a ‘good’ woman looks like.

  • Be considerate.
  • Be helpful.
  • Be accommodating.
  • Think about other people.
  • Don’t make a fuss.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with any of those qualities.

In fact, they’re often the foundations of strong relationships, successful careers and supportive communities.  But what happens when those qualities stop being choices?

When being helpful becomes an expectation?

When being accommodating becomes automatic?

When putting everybody else first becomes so familiar that we barely notice we’re doing it?

Over time, we can begin to absorb expectations that nobody is explicitly placing upon us.

We anticipate what other people need.

We volunteer before anybody asks.

We take responsibility because we know how.

And eventually, we may begin to measure our value through how useful we are to other people.

That’s where I think we need to become curious.

Because there’s a difference between choosing to support somebody and feeling obliged to do so simply because we’ve always been the person who helps.

When our strengths become our identities

Think about how you describe yourself.

Perhaps you’re organised.

Reliable.

Resilient.

Hard-working.

Independent.

The person who always finds a solution.

These are qualities we tend to celebrate.  And rightly so.

They help us navigate challenges, build careers, support people we care about and achieve things that matter to us.  But there’s an interesting point at which a strength can become an identity, and an identity can become an expectation.

If you’ve always been the dependable one, people expect you to be dependable.

If you’ve always been the strong one, people assume you can cope.

If you’ve always been the organiser, you become the person who remembers, anticipates and makes arrangements.

And if you’ve always been the person who works hard, you may begin to feel uncomfortable when you’re not working.

Not because anybody is demanding it.

But because you’ve become accustomed to seeing yourself that way.

When doing becomes who you are

I’ve spent much of my life working.

For more than 35 years, I’ve worked as an Executive Assistant, supporting senior leaders and navigating demanding professional environments.

Alongside that, I’ve run businesses, written books, developed coaching programmes and pursued all sorts of projects.

I enjoy creating things.

I enjoy learning.

I enjoy solving problems.

And I particularly enjoy seeing an idea develop into something tangible.

But I’ve also become increasingly aware of something about myself.

I sometimes struggle with not working.

Even when I have the opportunity to stop.

Even when there’s no pressing deadline.

Even when nobody is expecting anything from me.

I can always find something else I’d like to do.

Another idea.

Another project.

Another opportunity to develop something.

And because I enjoy those things, it can be easy to assume there’s nothing worth questioning.

But I’ve started to wonder whether enjoying something and feeling comfortable without it are necessarily the same thing.

Because there’s a difference between choosing to work because it brings you satisfaction, and feeling uncomfortable when you’re not being productive.

And I think that’s worth exploring.

Why choosing differently can feel uncomfortable

We often talk about personal change as though it’s primarily about learning new behaviours.

Setting boundaries.

Saying no.

Taking breaks.

Delegating.

Making time for ourselves.

But sometimes the practical behaviour isn’t the most difficult part.

It’s the identity attached to it.

If you’ve always been the person who helps, choosing not to help can feel uncomfortable.

If you’ve always been strong, admitting that you’re struggling can feel unfamiliar.

If you’ve always been productive, allowing yourself an afternoon without an agenda can feel like wasted time.

And if you’ve spent years being recognised for your capability, you may wonder how people will respond when you begin making different choices.

That’s where I think self-leadership becomes particularly interesting.

Because we’re not simply changing what we do.

We’re questioning what we’ve come to believe those behaviours say about who we are.

And that requires a different kind of awareness.

Recognising the pattern without judging yourself

One of the things I’ve been practising this year is becoming more comfortable with stopping.

Not because I want to abandon my ambitions.  Not because I’ve suddenly decided that work is a terrible thing.  And certainly not because I intend to spend the rest of my life doing absolutely nothing.

I genuinely enjoy much of what I do.

But I want to know that I’m choosing it.

That I can spend an afternoon working on something because it interests me.  And equally, that I can spend an afternoon doing something entirely different without feeling I ought to be more productive.

I haven’t mastered that.

And I’m not particularly concerned about mastering it.

Because this isn’t another performance target.

It’s an exercise in awareness.

Sometimes I notice myself looking for something useful to do.  And instead of immediately following that impulse, I get curious.

Why do I feel the need to do something?

Am I genuinely interested in the activity?

Am I avoiding something else?

Am I uncomfortable with having nothing planned?

Or is it simply a habit?

I don’t always need to change the behaviour.

But recognising it gives me the opportunity to choose.

And that, to me, is an important part of self-leadership.

The difference between responsibility and automatic behaviour

Within my Behind the Mask philosophy, I talk a great deal about personal responsibility.

I believe we have choices.

Sometimes those choices are difficult.

Sometimes they’re constrained by circumstances.

Sometimes choosing not to act is itself a decision.

But I also believe there’s an important distinction between consciously accepting responsibility and automatically repeating a behaviour because it’s familiar.

We can become so accustomed to fulfilling certain roles that we stop recognising the decisions involved.

We simply continue.

And perhaps that’s where the first step towards change begins.

Not with a dramatic declaration.

Not with a complete reinvention.

But with a question.

Am I still choosing this?

Because if the answer is yes, wonderful.

Continue.

Enjoy it.

Own it.

But if the answer is that you haven’t really considered it for years, perhaps it’s worth becoming curious.

You are allowed to be more than your strengths

I don’t want to stop being capable.

I don’t want to stop being ambitious.

I don’t want to stop working, creating, learning or contributing.

Those things are part of who I am.

But I don’t want them to become the whole of who I am.

And I suspect that’s something many capable women will recognise.

We can become so identified with being useful, dependable or resilient that we forget there are other parts of ourselves worth exploring.

The person who enjoys doing something simply because it’s fun.

The person who doesn’t always have the answer.

The person who occasionally needs support.

The person who can spend an afternoon doing nothing particularly productive.

The person who is still valuable when nobody needs anything from her.

Those parts of us matter too.

And perhaps the freedom we’re looking for isn’t freedom from responsibility.

Perhaps it’s freedom from the belief that we must always behave in the same way.

A question worth sitting with

So here’s something I’d invite you to consider.

What part of being ‘the strong one’ are you still choosing, and what part are you simply continuing because it’s who you’ve always been?

Don’t rush to change anything.

Don’t turn it into another project.

And don’t assume that recognising a pattern means there’s something wrong with you.

Simply become curious.

Because sometimes the most important change begins with awareness.

And sometimes the most defiant decision isn’t to do something extraordinary.

It’s to recognise that you don’t have to keep doing something simply because you’ve always done it.

Your strengths belong to you.

Your choices belong to you.

And you’re allowed to decide how you want to use them.

If you’d like a more structured way to explore those patterns, my 12-week Behind the Mask Self-Leadership programme offers guided reflection and practical exercises to help you understand your choices and take ownership of what comes next.

It’s £497, available to begin whenever you’re ready, and designed to work through at your own pace.